www.sqlpass.org    Professional Association for SQL Server

Election Review Committee Forums

Not logged in? Login here

The Election Review Committee wants to hear from you about PASS elections, past, present, and future. Feel free to use the forums below to have your say about anything and everything related to PASS elections. You can read what others said during the 2010 elections here.

Instructions

Log in to your sqlpass.org account (above or bottom of your page) and start posting. Really, that's it.

A few things to remember (aka "the rules"):

  • Please be respectful of others. Don't forget - everyone's a potential colleague!
  • Please refrain from abusive or profane behavior. There are better places than this forum for that.
  • Illegal activity and spam will not be tolerated. If you're unsure about what is and isn't kosher, you can refer to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use for reference.

Other than that, enjoy! If you have any questions or concerns about this forum, email Hannes at PASS HQ. If you have any private questions or concerns related to PASS elections, please email the ERC.

 

Scoring the Interview Portion
Last Post 04 May 2011 06:14 AM by Andy Leonard. 1 Replies.
Printer Friendly
Sort:
PrevPrev NextNext
You are not authorized to post a reply.
Author Messages
Brian KelleyUser is Offline
New Member
New Member
Posts:7
Avatar

--
06 Apr 2011 09:07 AM  
We'd like your feedback on how to score the interview. Details between the two methods we've come up with are here:
http://www.sqlservercentral.com/blo...rview.aspx
K. Brian Kelley, ERC member, USA Mid-Atlantic RM, Midlands PASS Chapter President
Andy LeonardUser is Offline
New Member
New Member
Posts:3
Avatar

--
04 May 2011 06:14 AM  
Hi Brian,

A thought-provoking post - good job!

I'm for public granular scores. I understand that, going in, interviews are tough and everyone has a bad day. The candidates get that. I understand some candidates have become frazzled enough during the PASS BoD Nomination Committee interview process to question their ability and desire to participate on the PASS Board. That's a clue.
We're not asking these people to make life or death decisions. They will never order soliders into harm's way. PASS leadership, when cornered regarding an obvious mistake, is quick to point out that they're a volunteer organizatino. During the NomCom interview process they're apparently demanding and decisive. I'd like to see the demanding and decisive stuff allocated to things like updating the SQL Saturday website, and the volunteer mindset applied to the interview process.

This isn't hard. If being allowed to appear on the slate presented for election is all about who plays nice with PASS, ditch the machinations, email the people whom the PASS Board approves, and ask them if they'd like to run for the Board. If PASS can't raise enough candidates using this method, then open a process to select more for the slate.

The disengenuous part of the election process is the attempt to make it appear fair when it's not. People understand that PASS wants who PASS wants and not that many are concerned (as evidenced by all the posts here). I believe people are even ok with PASS choosing who they want to lead - I know I am. I'm not ok (and I believe others agree) with PASS presenting a process and then circumventing it. Or standing behind process one day and then waffling on process a few weeks later. If the end result is going to always be "We decide who you can vote for, not you" then just be honest about that and move on (and fix the SQL Saturday site!).

PASS has a right to govern itself as it sees fit. This includes the right to exclude popular and capable leaders from consideration for election to the PASS Board for petty and arbitrary reasons. We get that. Next?

Andy
You are not authorized to post a reply.

Active Forums 4.2
The Professional Association for SQL Server (PASS) is an independent, not-for-profit association, dedicated to supporting, educating, and promoting the Microsoft SQL Server community. From local user groups and special interest groups (SIGs) to webcasts and the annual PASS Community Summit � the largest gathering of SQL Server professionals in the world � PASS enables knowledge sharing, in-depth learning, access to the Microsoft SQL Server team, and the ability to influence the direction of SQL Server technologies. PASS was founded in 1999 by Microsoft and CA and continues to enjoy executive level endorsement from both organizations. As the number one user community for Microsoft SQL Server, Microsoft looks to the PASS community for valued feedback, input, and inspiration. PASS Mission Empower the global Microsoft SQL Server community to connect, share, learn and be inspired through networking, knowledge sharing, peer-based learning, and the ability to influence the direction of Microsoft SQL Server products and services.

      

Forums
Blogs
Email

Election Review Committee

#PASSERC on Twitter

PASS Elections 2010 Home